Shopping Cart
There are no more items in your cart
Aftershave: Lotion or Balm?
Aftershave is one of the most misunderstood products in men's grooming. Many consider it simply optional or just another fragrance. The truth, however, is that it is a fundamental step in the shaving routine. So the question remains: aftershave lotion or balm? Which one is right for you?
✔️ Key differences
- Aftershave Lotion: Liquid and thin texture, like a lotion or gel.
- Aftershave Balm: Thicker and creamier, similar to a moisturizer or ointment.
Moisturizing properties
- Aftershave balm offers increased hydration, ideal for dry or sensitive skin.
- Lotion is lighter and often less moisturizing.
Ingredients
- Lotion contains more alcohol, offering a cooling and astringent effect.
- Balms usually contain natural ingredients such as aloe, shea butter, natural oils.
❤️ Skin types
- Balm is recommended for dry or sensitive skin due to its hydration.
- Lotion is better suited for oily skin due to its astringent action.
Alcohol content
- Lotion: 50–90% alcohol. Strong antiseptic action, but dehydrates.
- Balm: 2–5% or even none. Ideal for daily use without irritation.
Important note
Check the expiration date on each product. Balms require extra care in storage. Also read our article on the shelf life of aftershaves.
Fragrance
- Lotion: Intense and invigorating, often considered captivating.
- Balm: Mild fragrance, ideal for those who avoid strong scents.
Antimicrobial protection
- Lotion: Contains ethyl alcohol that neutralizes bacteria and viruses.
- Balm: Contains natural ingredients such as aloe and coconut with mild antibacterial action.
- For dry or sensitive skin: balm with moisturizing ingredients.
- For oily or normal skin: alcohol-based lotion.
✨ The choice depends on your skin type and your preference for fragrance and texture.
✂️ My Own Tests at the Barbershop
Giannis – Test on dry skin
"On a client with visible flaking on his cheeks, I tried aftershave balm with shea butter and aloe vera. There was no irritation at all and after 10 minutes his skin had completely calmed down. Since then, balm has become a standard choice for those with dry or troubled skin."
Giannis – Test with lotion on a young client
"A student who shaves every day and had oily skin in the T-zone asked me for something 'cleaner'. I applied a traditional lotion with mint. He felt immediate freshness and the oiliness disappeared. I saw him again after 3 weeks and he was still using it."
Giannis – Mixed use of lotion + balm
"We did a test with a regular client who generally had normal skin. I first used a little alcohol-based lotion for disinfection, and then a little balm on his cheeks. His skin remained clean, without redness and very moisturized. Since then, I recommend this combination to those who shave daily."
Texture
Aftershave Lotion is always in liquid form.
Aftershave Balm is available in cream form.
Aftershave lotion and aftershave balm are products used after shaving to soothe the skin and provide relief from any potential irritation caused by the shaving process. While they serve a similar purpose, there are some key differences between the two:
The differences are mainly found in:
Aftershave lotion typically has a thinner and more liquid consistency, similar to that of a traditional liquid or gel-based lotion. On the other hand, aftershave balm has a thicker and creamier texture, often resembling a moisturizer or ointment.
Moisturizing properties:
Aftershave balm tends to have more moisturizing properties compared to aftershave lotion. The balm's thicker texture allows it to provide greater hydration to the skin, making it beneficial for individuals with dry or sensitive skin.
Ingredients:
Aftershave lotion often contains a higher alcohol content compared to aftershave balm. Alcohol-based lotions have a cooling and astringent effect, helping to close pores and providing a refreshing sensation. Aftershave balms, on the other hand, usually have a lower or no alcohol content and may contain moisturizing ingredients such as shea butter, aloe vera, or various natural oils to nourish and soothe the skin.
Skin types:
Due to its moisturizing properties, aftershave balm is generally recommended for individuals with dry or sensitive skin. The added hydration can help replenish moisture lost during shaving and prevent dryness or irritation. Aftershave lotion, with its cooling and astringent effects, may be preferred by individuals with oilier skin types, as it can help minimize oiliness and provide a refreshing finish.
It is important to note that personal preferences may vary, and the choice between aftershave lotion and balm ultimately depends on the individual's skin type, preferences, and desired results.
Alcohol content
The aftershave lotion contains a significant percentage of ethyl alcohol. In most cases, an aftershave in lotion form consists of 50% alcohol. However, there are cases where the product may contain alcohol up to 90%.
· The percentage of alcohol contained in aftershave balm is very low, usually 2 to 5%. In fact, most products offered by companies no longer contain any alcohol.
CAUTION! Although aftershave lotion has a high alcohol content, you should pay attention to the product's expiration date, while special attention is required with aftershave balms. For further information, read our article on when aftershaves expire.
Fragrance
· Many men find aftershave lotion particularly invigorating because it has an intense scent. It is usually described as strong and captivating. The lotion's strong scent can make men feel more attractive.
· Compared to aftershave lotion, balm is gently scented, which is very often soothing and pleasant for those who do not prefer strong fragrances. In fact, there are several users who find its subtle scent comfortable and more refreshing.
Germ factor
· Ethyl alcohol, which is the main ingredient of lotion, is known for its disinfectant properties. It is capable of destroying many types of bacteria, viruses, and fungi. It is an excellent antiseptic for the skin that can keep it protected after shaving.
· Although balm contains small amounts of alcohol, its key ingredients, such as coconut oil and aloe vera, act as antibacterial agents.
Skin type
·Individuals with dry or sensitive skin should avoid using aftershave lotion due to the high amount of alcohol. Alcohol, as we know, is a dehydrating agent because it neutralizes moisture from the skin. Therefore, applying alcohol-based products can actually worsen dry skin.
Aftershave balm, because it has a lower alcohol content, is ideal for dry skin. Also, many contain essential oils, which act as a natural moisturizer. In reality, however, balms have been formulated for sensitive, dry, and normal skin types. They are suitable for all skin types.
✅ What is Aftershave and why do we use it
Aftershave is applied after shaving to soothe the skin, prevent irritation, and disinfect any minor cuts. Depending on its composition, it can provide hydration, protection from bacteria, and of course... a wonderful fragrance!
✅ Aftershave Lotion: The traditional one
Lotion is liquid and often contains alcohol. It is used for disinfection and leaves an intense feeling of freshness. It is ideal for men with oily skin, as it dries quickly and reduces oiliness.
Advantages:
- Immediately disinfects the skin
- Leaves a cool sensation
- Ideal for oily skin
Disadvantages:
- Often contains alcohol that dries the skin
- Not suitable for sensitive skin
✅ Aftershave Balm: The gentle choice
Balm has a thicker, creamy texture and does not contain alcohol. It is designed to moisturize and soothe the skin, without stinging. Ideal for dry or sensitive skin, and especially for men who want a gentler post-shave experience.
Advantages:
- Moisturizes and soothes
- Without irritating elements
- Suitable for dry or sensitive skin
Disadvantages:
- Does not have the same disinfectant action as lotion
- May leave a "heavier" feeling on oily skin
✅ Which one to choose?
If you have oily skin, can tolerate the sensation of alcohol, and want something cool, then prefer an aftershave lotion. Conversely, if your skin is sensitive, dry, or you are bothered by a burning sensation, then balm is the ideal choice.
Many men choose to have both in their collection and use them depending on the season, skin needs, or even mood!
✅ Extra Tip: Aftershave with or without fragrance?
If you wear perfume daily, prefer a neutral or unscented aftershave so that the fragrances do not mix. If you like to maintain a subtle masculine scent, then choose an aftershave with a fragrance that suits you.
✅ Conclusion
The choice between aftershave lotion and balm depends mainly on your skin type and your personal preferences. The important thing is not to skip this step. Aftershave completes the shaving experience and helps your skin stay healthy, hydrated, and clean.
Comments (1)